The missing year of Chicago's most prestigious championship
Photographs courtesy of USGA Museum & Library
This article appeared in the November 2026 edition of Chicago District Golfer.
To read more Chicago District Golfer stories, head to our article archive.
Willie Smith plays his tee shot on the 12th hole during the 1901 U.S. Open at Myopia Hunt Club in South Hampton, Mass.
It took Scotland centuries to embrace golf. Chicago needed only about five years. By the late 1890s, more than two dozen formal golf clubs dotted the city. In April 1899, civic leaders formed the Western Golf Association (WGA), modeled after New York’s Metropolitan Golf Association. “Western” meant any club within 500 miles of Chicago. Top priorities: an amateur championship and a standardized handicap system.
During late-July planning, organizers realized they had extra funds. On a whim, they added a one-day professional “open” tournament the day before the amateur event. The purse was modest – $75, $50 and $25 for the top three – with a $2 entry fee. The announcement appeared in Chicago papers on Aug. 1.
The Boycott: Oconomowoc, Wisconsin
That same Aug. 1 morning, top professionals were boarding a train to Oconomowoc, Wisconsin. Golf pro Alex Smith and wealthy club member Walter Dupee had quietly organized a new event with a $250 purse, no entry fee and free train travel. When news of what they felt was the WGA’s skimpy offer broke, Smith – respected as a natural leader – used the three-hour train ride to rally his colleagues.
The professionals objected to the tiny purse, the $2 fee (which would leave most of them in the red) and the fact that only the amateur champion would receive a medal. That night at Lac La Belle, they issued the “Oconomowoc Proclamation,” unanimously boycotting the Western Open. News of the boycott hit the next morning's papers in Chicago. Most of the professionals were employed by WGA founding clubs, and many of the club presidents were furious. Once home, some pros quickly folded under pressure.
A Second Olive Branch
Wanting a full field, the WGA responded by adding a gold medal for the pro winner and stretching the $150 purse across five places. Still, several holdouts, including current U.S. Open champion Fred Herd, Alex Smith and members of the Foulis family, stayed away.
Willie Smith, Alex’s younger brother and professional at Midlothian Country Club, faced a painful choice. His boss and close friend George Thorne, who was the WGA Treasurer, Midlothian founder and brother-in-law/partner to Montgomery Ward, urged him to play. Thorne had helped shape the WGA and even donated the silver trophy for the Amateur Champion. Willie Smith decided to play.
On Sept. 6, 1899, at Glen View Club, a field of just 16 competed in the inaugural Western Open. Willie Smith and local pro Laurie Auchterlonie tied after 36 holes. In the 18-hole playoff the next day, Willie pulled away dramatically, winning by 10 strokes. As master of ceremonies, a beaming George Thorne presented the gold medal and the $50 prize. During the congratulatory handshake, with a wink and a nod, Thorne quietly palmed Willie an extra $50 bill.
One week later, 23-year-old Willie Smith won the U.S. Open by a record 11 strokes (a margin that stood until Tiger Woods’ 15-stroke victory in 2000). When he returned to Chicago, he presented the engraved U.S. Open trophy to Thorne to adorn the Midlothian front lobby.
The Western Open Disappears—Then Returns
In 1900, the WGA, still smarting from the boycott, dropped the Western Open. Oconomowoc doubled its purse and drew even bigger stars. Newspapers predicted it might be “many a moon” before another Western professional championship.
1901– Alex Smith Moves to New York, and Willie Smith Takes Charge
Willie Smith became Chicago’s leading pro and, in June 1901, quietly approached Thorne about reviving the event. Trusting their strong relationship, Thorne pushed the issue. At his insistence, the WGA board met on July 10, 1901, and unanimously approved a revived Western Open with a $300 purse plus a gold medal. Midlothian would host.
On Aug. 20, 1901, a full field competed without incident. The tournament had survived its turbulent birth. The Oconomowoc Open field went on to dominate the Western Open, winning 10 of the first twelve Western Opens. They also dominated the U.S. Open, winning 10 times between 1896 and 1910.
Today, the Western Open – now the BMW Championship – offers a $20 million purse, with $3.6 million to the winner. The early drama of boycotts, solidarity, persuasion and level-headed governance laid the foundation for the modern professional game.
David Mackesey is the author of the book “From Country Estate to Country Club, The History of Diablo Country Club.” He serves as Historian for Carnoustie [Scotland] Golf Club, Diablo Country Club in California, The Club at Lac La Belle [Oconomowoc, Wisconsin], and is the founder of the [Alex] Smith Society.